cheddar dill sourdough rolls
i’ve always considered dill to be a second tier herb.
my mother cooked with a multitude of herbs, often, even growing chives and green onions in our backyard.
during peak harvest times, my mother would cook nothing but chives for weeks at a time — chive dumplings, chive bao zi, chive pockets. she fed it all to my brother and i until we became bloated from the fiber.
dill just never had a place in my pantry. never harmonized with the warming notes of our rotation of ginger, star anise, and chilis, never made it into our cart during our biweekly trips to shanghai supermarket.
in the past few months, however, i’ve been flirting a lot with dill. a dill-less salad now feels naked, like it’s missing an ingredient as crucial as the lettuce itself. i’ll never leave another PLS ungarnished.
above all, i’ve become hooked on the combination of cheese and dill after trying a roll from la farine.
with the feedback of over seven taste testers, i’ve developed a delicate, puffy, pizza-crust like roll that similarly centers cheddar and dill.
this roll has a crisp and thin crust, encrusted with thinly shredded cheddar and speckled with fresh dill. bready walls surround a small divet where the cheddar pools and bubbles. when you bite in, it’s like eating a sauceless, herby micro pizza.
no matter where you are in your relationship with dill, these rolls will make you fall in love all over again. bread and cheese tend to have that kind of effect.
notes
the secret to the perfect texture and bite is using olive oil instead of flour while shaping! it is of utmost importance that you use as little flour as possible during this step!
i encourage swapping the dill for chives or scallions for a different flavor profile. in fact, i’ve tested this with scallions and the result is just as wonderful (see the three rolls in the left corner of the cover photo).
though i haven’t tried it, gruyere could also be a nice cheese accompaniment to the dill.
if your cheddar is on the saltier side, i would skip the extra salt. the cheddar i used was pretty mild.
as always, my starter is 80% hydration. please adjust the dough formula to match your starter. all timing and schedules are suggestions. i developed this recipe in springtime san francisco kitchen at about 74°F.
baker’s percentage & sample timetable
the percentages for water and flour only account for the final dough build, and do not include the levain formula build.
ingredient | baker’s percentage |
bread flour | 95% |
whole wheat flour | 5% |
water | 78% |
salt | 2.5% |
levain | 24% |
cheddar cheese | 32% |
fresh dill | 4% |
step | time |
levain build | 6 hours |
bulk rise | 8-9 hours |
folds | 6 folds |
cold proof | 16 hours |
bake | 15 min |
cheddar dill sourdough rolls
formula
- 8 g unfed levain
- 8 g king arthur whole wheat flour
- 32 g king arthur all purpose flour
- 32 g water @ 85°F
- 190 g king arthur bread flour
- 10 g king arthur whole wheat flour
- 156 g water @ 95°F
- 5 g salt
- 48 g ripe levain
- extra virgin olive oil
- 64 g sharp cheddar cheese, shredded
- 8 g fresh dill, chopped finely
- 1 tsp salt (optional, to taste)
method
- refresh your starter using the levain build formula, and stiff starter method.
- in my current kitchen of 74°F, it takes about 5-6 hrs for my starter to ripen. in a cold wintertime 60°F kitchen, it might take closer to 10 hrs.
- in a large bowl, mix all flours together. slowly add the water, mixing with a rubber spatula, making sure to incorporate the water into the flour well, stopping when all the flour is hydrated.
- let sit, covered, for 30-60 minutes.
- sprinkle salt evenly over the autolysed dough. incorporate gently by folding dough over a 2-3 times.
- then, measure out the ripe starter, and add to the bowl.
- with wet hands, mix. i first use the pincer method. then, i alternate between the stretch & fold and the slap & fold method for about 6-7 minutes.
- let dough rise until it is 1.2x in volume and appears gaseous, about 8-9 hours in a 74°F kitchen.
- this dough needs 5-6 sets of coil folds, spaced 30-45 min apart, starting at the beginning.
- sample schedule:– 2:30 pm fold #1– 3:00 pm fold #2– 3:30 pm fold #3– 4:00 pm fold #4– 4:45 pm fold #5– 5:30 pm fold #6
- choose a large plate or vessel to place your final 8 dough balls. remember that they'll expand a little in the fridge.
- generously oil the bottom (and sides) of the vessel. oil will act as the primary non-stick agent.
- using as little flour as possible, dust a working surface. gently dump the dough onto your lightly floured surface.
- again, using as little flour as possible, divide the dough into 8 even pieces. i keep cutting pieces evenly in half until i reach 8.
- if your fingers are sticking to the dough, cover them lightly in oil.
- one by one, use the stretch and fold method to form a ball with a tightly closed bottom. flip the ball, seam side down, on an unfloured surface. tug gently and twist slightly to seal.
- generously oil the top and sides of the dough ball before placing into your vessel. repeat with all 8 balls.
- once the balls are shaped, cover them with plastic wrap, or place the entire vessel in a sealed, extra large, gallon ziploc bag.
- whatever you use, you'll want to make sure the seal is airtight and that they are completely covered so they do not dry out (this means cloth does not work).
- place in fridge and proof for 14-16 hours.
- preheat oven to 500°F.
- to make the topping, mix the thinly shredded cheddar cheese together with dill. add salt, if needed, to taste.
- remove the dough balls from the fridge. they should look like they held their shape for the most part, and like they have expanded slightly.
- cover a sheet pan with parchment paper.
- with oiled hands, take one dough ball and set onto the sheet pan, remembering to leave space for all the others.
- using your thumb, indent the center of the dough so that it makes an imprint. using your other fingers, press to widen the indent so it makes a divet, about the size of a quarter.
- moving quickly, take a small scoop of the cheese topping and press it into the divet you just formed. it is totally normal for the divet to start closing immediately! not to worry at all. just use your fingers to press the topping in.
- gently cover the rest of the roll with additional cheese mixture.
- repeat with all the remaining rolls until you have all 8 evenly filled and evenly spaced out on the sheet pan.
- place sheet pan on middle rack of oven.
- bake at 500°F for 5 minutes. then, lower to 475°F and bake for an additional 10 min. you'll want the cheese to look golden or golden brown, but not dark brown or burnt.
- let cool for 15 minutes. serve immediately by themselves, or with some beer & pickles.
- store up to a few days in a tupperware container.
- to reheat, pop in the microwave for 15 seconds or in the air fryer for a few minutes.